Monday, July 25, 2016

Arguments I’ve had with Shengwu Li, part 1: should you vote?


This piece comes from conversations with my housemate, Shengwu, who is leaving us for Harvard. We are all sad about this; I am sad about it in part because Sheng has sharpened my thinking as much as anyone I know. I still remember the first time we talked about math; sitting at a coffee shop I thought, shit, this guy with the Oxbridge accent and the penchant for Latin phrases might actually be as smart as he sounds. You won’t find someone who’s more fluent talking about both math and morality, and you won’t get a better intellectual guarantee than “this argument is Shengwu-proof” . I’m not really sure what we’ll do without him -- less rigorous social science, I guess. Any errors in this analysis remain my own.


Here are two questions we’ve been arguing about recently.


  1. Is it rational to vote in a national US election just because of the remote possibility you could change which candidate wins?
  2. How much does sleeping through the first round of the debate world championships hurt your final result?  


I’m going to talk about the first argument in this post and the second argument in a later post because I’ve been informed that there’s a limit to how much other people want to listen to Sheng and I argue.


There are many arguments for voting -- “what would happen if no one did?” “people died for your right to vote!” -- but let’s consider a crazy one: you should vote because you might be the tie-breaking vote in an election. Obviously, this is incredibly unlikely. On the other hand, if you did, it would be incredibly important. So just how unlikely is it?


Say you live in a state with a million expected voters where one candidate is polling at 52% and the other at 48%. Here’s a first attempt at figuring out how likely you are to be the tying vote: if each voter is like a coin with a 52% chance of landing heads, what is the probability you get exactly 50% heads? The answer is so small -- less than one in 10100 -- that the computer returns 0. If you run a bunch of simulations of the fraction of heads, it looks like this -- pretty much every time you’ll end up with a fraction close to .52.


This implies that voting is a waste of time; you have no chance of influencing the outcome. But this simple analysis turns out to be wrong for a simple reason: polls aren’t perfect. Just because a poll tells you 52% of voters prefer a candidate doesn’t mean that 52% of voters actually do. One source of error is the margin of error in polls: as the Upshot pointed out recently, because pollsters only sample a relatively small group of people, polling results fluctuate just due to random noise. So if a poll tells you that 52% of voters prefer a candidate, the real percentage might be something like:




Which is a lot more uncertainty than we saw before.


Given this uncertainty, it turns out the chance that you're the tying vote is not that low -- somewhere between 1 in 100,000 and 1 in 10 million (see [1] if you want modeling details). Which sounds low but is actually astonishingly high. If the difference in value between the two candidates is, say, a trillion dollars -- which is plausible, given the size of the US budget and the very different uses Trump and Clinton would put it to -- then a 1 in 10 million chance of influencing the election outcome means that in expectation, you change the allocation of $100,000. Of course, I’ve only simulated a single state, not the whole election, using a very simple model. But after doing this I discovered a more sophisticated analysis from Andrew Gelman, Nate Silver, and Aaron Edlin which reached a similar conclusion: if you live in a state which is at all close, voting is probably worth your while simply because of the possibility you will be the tie-breaking vote in an election. If you are trying to decide whether your state is at all close, err on the side of “yes”; here are 538's predictions for every state.


This was surprising to both of us; I am definitely going to vote now (in Virginia, a swing state), and you should too!

Addendum: a corollary to this is that you should not vote for a third party candidate on the grounds that "my vote will never matter anyway, so I'll just vote my conscience". Vote for a third party candidate if you want to, but if your state is at all close -- and current polls imply that many states will be -- weigh your desire to vote your conscience against the fact that, mathematically, your vote really could affect the outcome of the election.


Notes:

[1] Very simple model: draw the true fraction of voters ut preferring a candidate from a normal, ut  ~ N(up, sigma), where up is the fraction preferring a candidate according to polls and sigma is the uncertainty on the polls (due not just to margin of error but to other things as well); then draw the number of voters voting for a candidate, V, from a binomial distribution, V ~ binom(T, ut), where T is the total number of voters. What is the probability that V = T / 2?

49 comments:

  1. I believe this is a common argument used by political scientists. Another argument is that the sort of policies candidates prefer are reflective of the sort of policies voters prefer. By voting you change the policies candidates campaign on. I don't think it's a coincidence that the demographic which votes the most also receives the most money from the government.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Isn't the problem with this argument that any close election will almost automatically go to a recount, which ultimately ends up being decided by things like who wins a write-in vote for "Rick Parry"?

    ReplyDelete
  3. But there's still a number of votes at which the outcome changes from "candidate X wins" to "too close too call," right?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not sure a valuation of $1 trillion is justified, at least for your generic presidential election. The only (realistic) policy difference I can think of that can move the needle that much is leading us into a war. Of course, even a valuation of $100 billion is more than enough reason to vote.

    What I'm really writing about is to add another argument, which is that you should vote in the presidential election because you should vote in the down-ballot races.

    That is, your vote probably matters somewhere else on the ballot, from your neighborhood dog-catcher to the school board to your state representatives. Even with incumbency advantage and non-competitive races, chances are pretty good that there's *some* office or ballot measure that you care about and is competitive.

    I'm curious: what's Shengwu's argument?

    Finally, what if you have a poll of polls? Wouldn't that reduce a lot of uncertainty? 538 has 28 polls for Florida, for example.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It's not unreasonable to assume that the electoral college—humans, just like all the rest of us—can be swayed one way or the other by financial or other means. Considering they are essentially the gatekeepers of the presidency, is it not a very real possibility that your vote, be it the statistical tie-breaker or not, doesn't count all?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Some other argument is that the sort of guidelines candidates decide on is reflective of the form of regulations citizens pick. by way of balloting, you change the regulations candidates marketing campaign on. The simplest (practical) coverage distinction i will consider that may flow the needle that tons are leading us right into warfare. Dissertation Proposal Writing Help

    ReplyDelete
  7. Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280Call now 09336801280 call boy Play boy service provider all India ki all City mey services available full secret service provider koi Dhokha dhadhi nhi full maza Masti key saath pasaa kamye (50000 sey 90000 per month)call me 09336801280

    ReplyDelete
  8. During detox, there ought to be consideration regarding the general wholesome needs of the fiend, since liquor and drugs can both negatively affect the body. What's more, since detox can be an exceptionally passionate encounter, enthusiastic help advising is a fundamental piece of the drug detox program. At the point when the individual is finished with detox, they are prepared to proceed with the drug rehab program.
    quotes for people fighting addictions
    addiction quotes

    ReplyDelete
  9. What a motivational post which encourage those people who want to take the challenges as they are face many problem with quality essay writing

    ReplyDelete
  10. Arguments during elections or voting, in my opinion, are most likely assumptions. Therefore, it is better to pay attention to the experience of other countries that have faced the problem with the introduction of quarantine restrictions, how to provide conditions for a campaign, and organize voting in quarantine. Despite all the limitations in the world, the team of services for writing https://thesisleader.com/revise-my-paper/ works non-stop. Young people are recommended to study, not to stop, and to step forward. Build a happy future.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Your blogs are authentic and great. Are you also searching for cheap nursing writing company? we are the best solution for you. We are best known for delivering quality essay writing services to students without having to break the bank

    ReplyDelete
  12. I want to testify on how I got cured from Herpes. I have been living with this disease for the past 11 months, i have done all i can to cure this disease but all my efforts proved abortive until i met an old friend of mine who told me about a herbal doctor called Dr Oniha, she told me that Dr Oniha have cure for all kinds of diseases, though i never believed in it because my believe was that there is no cure for Herpes disease. But I decided to give it a try when I contacted Dr Oniha, he told me he has a cure for herpes that he cured with herbal medicine. I order for the herbal medicine, which Dr Oniha sent to me through a courier service which i make use of and now behold the herpes is gone and i now have my life back,if you are out there living with this disease i will like you to also contact Dr Oniha and get this disease cured out of your body. I am a living testimony of Dr Oniha herbal cure. Thanks once again Dr Oniha for you are God sent. contact Dr oniha through his contact information.
    Email:driyaseherblahoe@gmail.com
    Whatsapp number: +2347057052206

    ReplyDelete
  13. I read the whole blog, and I think you had a crazy argument. However, I want to know one thing, can you suggest any US Essay Writer who can help me finish all of the essays my teacher has given to me. It’s like my wrist is fractured, and my typing speed has gotten slow. So, therefore, I require someone to guide me and get all of my tasks done.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The Move Me Professional Movers and Packers in Dubai. Contact us today for professional movers in Dubai. Make your move stress-free with The Move Me movers and packers in Dubai, UAE.
    local movers dubai

    ReplyDelete
  15. Searching for take my online class or do my class online for me? Get the best online class help from Online Classes Hub. We take your classes and courses.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Apollo pg slot เป็นเกมสล็อตออนไลน์ จากค่ายเกม PG SLOT เกมสล็อตแตกง่ายมาในแบบ สล็อตแนวดิ่ง เล่นสล็อตโทรศัพท์เคลื่อนที่ ล่นง่ายได้เงินจริง เกมออกใหม่ ของค่ายเกม apollo pg slot

    ReplyDelete
  17. To know about AI automated help desk and service desk with rezolve.ai click here: https://bit.ly/3MyfJ5Q

    ReplyDelete
  18. 토토사이트
    스포츠중계
    스포츠토토티비
    When someone writes an post he/she keeps the idea of a user in his/her mind that how a user can be aware of it. Thus that’s why this article is perfect. Thanks!|

    ReplyDelete
  19. 토토

    Hi there, You have done a great job. I will definitely digg it and
    personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this web site.

    ReplyDelete
  20. 토토
    스포츠토토

    Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part �� I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this certain information for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

    ReplyDelete
  21. 토토사이트
    먹튀검증
    토토

    Just a smiling visitor here to share the love (:, btw outstanding layout.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information.บา คา ร่า วอ เลท

    ReplyDelete
  23. I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious...สล็อต ฝาก-ถอน true wallet ไม่มี บัญชีธนาคาร

    ReplyDelete
  24. Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us.เว็บสล็อตเว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return.เว็บ ตรง

    ReplyDelete
  26. Very nice article. To know about AI automated service desk and helpdesk at MS teams, visit the website and schedule demo. Click here:
    microsoft teams hr help desk

    ReplyDelete
  27. pg slot ฝาก 99 รับ 300 ปัจจุบัน ในทันที โดยเป็นรับโบนัสสามารถรับ ได้ในทันที สำหรับสมาชิกทุกท่านที่มาร่วมเล่นเกมสล็อตออนไลน์กับพวกเรา ยิ่งกว่านั้นยังมีโปร PG SLOT เด็ดๆพร้อมบริการ

    ReplyDelete
  28. I have read your excellent post. This is a great job. I have enjoyed reading your post first time. I want to say thanks for this post. Thank you... Kindly Visit our Website:- Reset Roadrunner Email Password

    ReplyDelete
  29. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  30. หลายท่านรู้จักตัว สล็อตเว็บตรง กันเป็นอย่างมากเพราะเป็นค่ายที่ตัวเกมส์สนุกสนานและได้เงินจริงในสมัยก่อนค่าย PG slot ยังเล่นได้แต่ในคอมพิวเตอร์แต่ในปัจจุบันทาง PG slotได้อัปเดตระบบทางเข้าPG slot มือถือ เสร็จเป็นที่เรียบร้อยแล้วเพื่อให้ผู้เล่นที่ไม่มีคอมพิวเตอร์หรือเวลาออกไปไหนมาไหนก็สามารถเล่นและสร้างรายได้จาก PG slot

    ReplyDelete
  31. ผู้เล่นสล็อตออนไลน์ส่วนใหญ่รู้จัก สล็อตเว็บตรง กันเป็นอย่างดีเพราะเป็นเว็บตรง PGที่โด่งดังเพราะว่า เป็นเว็บตรง PGที่มีตัวเกมส์หลากหลาย แตกง่าย และแจกเงินรางวัลมากมายให้กับผู้เล่นสล็อตออนไลน์ ลูดค้าที่เล่นสล็อตออนไลน์ เว็บตรง PG เลยหลงรักและหลงใหลกับตัวเกมส์กันเป็นอย่างมาก

    ReplyDelete
  32. Thanks for the blog very nice keep going. Go to crystal shops near me and you will learn that crystals are said to have a stable and unchanging energy pattern, each with a unique frequency and energy field, or resonance, that gives them special properties.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Vacuum Insulated Glass (VIG) is an insulated glass with a vacuum layer between two rigidly held panes of glass

    ReplyDelete
  34. Thanks for sharing such an Informative post, Really it is very intresting and I also share the best Relocation Company in Trivandrum

    ReplyDelete

  35. "Arguments I've had with Shengwu Li, Part 1: Should You Vote?" explores the contentious topic of voting. This engaging series delves into the significance of civic participation, weighing the importance of exercising one's right to vote and examining contrasting viewpoints. It sets the stage for a thought-provoking discussion on an essential democratic practice. are protective orders public record in virginia

    ReplyDelete
  36. Discover the AMH Test Price in Delhi. If you are curious about the price of the AMH test in the bustling city of Delhi, you have come to the right place. The AMH test, also known as the Anti-Mullerian Hormone test, is a valuable tool used to assess a woman's ovarian reserve and fertility potential.

    By measuring the levels of AMH in the blood, this test can provide insights into a woman's reproductive health and help in determining the best course of action for family planning.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Shengwu Li posits a thought-provoking argument, questioning the significance of an individual vote in the vast sea of ballots. Does one vote hold substantial weight in determining election outcomes, or does it get lost amidst the collective voice of the electorate?
    lawyers for bankruptcy near me

    ReplyDelete

  38. COLL NOW 09818592392call COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE GIGOLO इस में बड़े घरानों की महिलाएं अपने साथ सेक्स करने के लिए युवा लड़कों को पैसे देती है उसे जिगोलो कहते हैं इन लड़कों से सेवाएं लेने वाली महिलाएं अमीर अय्याश महिलाएं भी बड़े घरानों की होती है जो एक बार के 16000 से 26000 हजार रुपए देती है अगर आप भी जिगोलो बन कर पैसे कमाना चाहते हैं तो जल्द ही हम से संपर्क करें COLL NOW 09818592392call COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE महिलाओं की उम्र 20 से 45 वर्ष SEX SERVICE समय एक सप्ताह में दो से तीन लड़कियों या महिलाओं को SEX SERVICE देना होता है माश्र दो से तीन घंटे स्थान आप के शहर से 50 से 100 किलोमीटर के आस पास बड़े शहरों में फाइफ स्टार होटल या उनके बंगले पर अब डरने और शरमाने का समय नहीं है अब MALE और FEMALE हर एक मीटिंग में 16000 से 26000 कमाओं और अपनी जिंदगी के हर एक पल का मजा लो HIGH SOCIETY के लड़के और लड़कियों के साथ आप के आप ने ही CITY में आज ही ज्वाइन होने के लिए काल करें COLL NOW 09818592392call COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE दोस्तों फेसबुक पर आप को कोई हाउसवाइफ सीधा संपर्क नहीं करेंगी वो सुरक्षा चाहतीं हैं प्राइवेसी चाहतीं हैं इसलिए वो कंपनियों के जरिए मिलेगी SEX SERVICE में आप को अमीर घरों की लड़कियों महिलाओं के साथ दोस्ती SEX सम्बंध बना कर उन्हें खुश करना होता है यह वह महिलाएं होती हैं जिनके HUSBAND अक्सर उनसे दूर रहते हैं इसीलिए उन्हें अपनी शारीरिक जरूरत पूरी करने के लिए GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY की आवश्यकता होती है वह GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY को इसीलिए बुलाती है क्यों की वह वदनामी के डर से आस पड़ोस में सम्बंध नहीं बनाती है इसीलिए वह GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY को बुलाती है क्यों कि GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY उन को नहीं जानते है और ना ही उन का घर क्यों कि मीटिंग होटल में होती है GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY SERVICE में मिलने वाला वेतन आप को एक मीटिंग का 16000 से 26000 रुपये हर मीटिंग का मिलेगा आपको पहली मीटिंग का 25% कमीशन देना होगा और आप को बाकी सभी मीटिंगों का 50% कमीशन मीटिंग के बाद कंपनी को देना होगा आप अपनी इच्छानुसार किसी भी टाइम की मीटिंग लें सकते हैं यह GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE भारत के सभी छोटे बड़े शहरों में उपलब्ध है आप अपनी इच्छानुसार किसी भी शहर में GIGOLO COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE लें सकते हैं जिस दिन आप की रजिस्ट्रेशन SERVICE फीस जमा होगी पहली मीटिंग उसी दिन होगी JOIN होने के लिए नीचे मांगी गई DETAILS WHATSAPP 09818592392call पर भेजे आप को अपना कोई भी एक आई डी देना होगा और एक पासपोर्ट फोटो देना होगा और जिस शहर में SERVICE करना है उस का नाम WHATSAPP करो और आज हमारे साथ हजारों MALE FEMALE काम कर रहे हैं 100% गोपनीय COLL NOW 09818592392call COLL BOY PLAY BOY SEX SERVICE

    ReplyDelete