Thursday, January 15, 2015

The Illusion of Agreement: #CrimingWhileWhite, #AliveWhileBlack, and #LeelahAlcorn

This post discusses Leelah Alcorn, a transgender girl who committed suicide.


The Atlantic’s Quartz just published an analysis I worked on with Gilad Lotan [1] about how people discuss race on Twitter using the hashtags #CrimingWhileWhite and #AliveWhileBlack. You should read the piece (cmon -- I was writing this over Christmas) but in brief, the results are more hopeful than my earlier, depressing analysis of how people discussed Ferguson. When studying Ferguson, I found that different social groups expressed opposite views, rarely talked, and were often hostile when they did; studying #CrimingWhileWhite/#AliveWhileBlack revealed that while different social groups expressed different views, they weren’t opposite views, and information sometimes spread between groups in a constructive way.


Good signs! Unfortunately, this apparent improvement may be somewhat illusory. In the Ferguson discussion, conservatives and liberals often clashed; in the #CrimingWhileWhite and #AliveWhileBlack discussion, conservatives appear to have mostly disappeared. So it’s not that people all agree; it’s that those who disagree are silent. It’s not that the schisms that scar Twitter have healed; we’ve just zoomed in on part of the landscape.


Here’s another example of this. On December 28, Leelah Alcorn, a teenager who was born Josh Alcorn but identified as female, committed suicide and posted a note blaming her parents’ intolerance. The story spread rapidly on Twitter, where people overwhelmingly supported Leelah and blamed her parents. One of the clearest ways to see this is in the gender people used when referring to Leelah: while her mother used male pronouns, Leelah used female pronouns. Tweeters were hundreds of times more likely to use “Leelah” than “Josh”, and pronouns also show a dramatic skew. In the graph below, the green line shows the proportion of tweets that use “Josh”; the blue line shows the proportion of tweets that use “Leelah” [2].




The green spike at the beginning is due to local tweeters who were offering condolences before the suicide note had been published. Their use of “Josh” implies that Leelah’s preferred identity was not widely known (or, perhaps, ignored) among those who knew her. (One tweeter who used male pronouns defended himself by saying, “She went to my school but I didn’t know she was trans”).  


It would, of course, be wrong to conclude from this that there is overwhelming acceptance of transgender Americans. A survey of LGBT Americans found that just 3% believed there was a lot of acceptance of transgender adults. Two explanations seem more plausible: the people who would refer to Leelah with male pronouns either aren’t on Twitter, or aren’t choosing to comment in the aftermath of her suicide.


As I write in the Quartz piece, we need more than this illusory uniformity; we need fierce but productive dissent. The internet tantalizes us with its ability to create a single human overmind, but at the moment that mind’s had its corpus callosum severed. Please write to me if you have thoughts on


  1. how to get people with very different worldviews to have productive discussions of controversial issues
  2. how to search Twitter (or other areas of the internet) for signs that these discussions are occurring.


Notes:

[1] A Twitter expert. He does professionally what I only dabble in, and has studied everything from ISIS to Israel.

17 comments:

  1. I am interested in seeing how groups with different worldviews link to articles or essays in social media. It might be a way to identify what kind of writing speaks to both sides. The article (or tv/newscasts/video) data might need some sifting to differentiate between polarizing both sides and inspiring both sides, but I think the mining would be worthwhile. It could help formulate methods/models for productive conversations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a good idea! It would be cool to find the articles that liberals and conservatives tend to most agree on and most disagree on. Often I think it's just that they're reading entirely different things.

      Delete
    2. Ahaha yes, the force that will bring us all back together :)

      Delete
  2. I desired to thanks for this good go through!! I unquestionably enjoying each small bit of it I have you bookmarked to take a look at new things you publish.สล็อต 999

    ReplyDelete
  3. I discovered that web page quite usefull which survey is rather cirious, I ' ve under no circumstances noticed a site that demand a study for this steps, incredibly curious...สล็อตวอเลท

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your function is superb And that i respect you and hopping for some a lot more enlightening posts. Thanks for sharing great details to us.สล็อตแตกง่าย

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tremendous-Duper website! I'm Loving it!! Will return once again, Im taking your feed also, Thanks.บา คา ร่า วอ เลท

    ReplyDelete
  6. Many thanks for a fascinating weblog. What else might I get that kind of info written in these types of a great technique? I have an endeavor that i'm just now running on, and I are actually on the lookout for such details.สล็อตทรูวอเลท

    ReplyDelete
  7. I believe That is an instructive post and it is extremely helpful and proficient. Hence, I would want to thanks to the endeavors that you've created in composing this text. The many information is totally effectively-researched. Many thanks...สล็อตแตกง่าย

    ReplyDelete
  8. You have carried out an awesome work on this information. It’s extremely exact and really qualitative. You've even managed to make it readable and simple to examine. You have got some real creating talent. Thank you much.สล็อตxo

    ReplyDelete
  9. Awesome report, it had been incredibly helpful! I just began Inside this and I'm beginning to be considerably more acquainted with it considerably superior! Cheers, maintain carrying out good!เว็บสล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow, What an amazing post. I truly located this to Considerably informatics. It is what I used to be trying to locate.I want to endorse you that make sure to go on to maintain sharing these kind of details.Many thanksเว็บสล็อตเว็บตรง

    ReplyDelete
  11. You there, this is definitely excellent report beneath. Many thanks for taking the time to publish this type of valuable information and facts and specifics. High quality published content is precisely what normally gets the men and women coming.เว็บตรงสล็อต

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wow! These an amazing and valuable post This is certainly definitely. I actually certainly uncover it irresistible. It is so wonderful and so amazing. I'm just shocked. I hope you continue to finish your work similar to this Down the road alsoเว็บ ตรง

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi there I'm so delighted I Found your weblog, I really Identified you by miscalculation, when I was observing on google for an additional matter, In almost any scenario I am appropriate below now and will very similar to to convey thank for a wonderful report along with a all spherical entertaining Website. Be sure you do keep up The nice accomplish.สล็อตเว็บใหญ่

    ReplyDelete
  14. Certainly I'm extensively agreed using this type of brief short article And that i just want say that this small article is quite terrific and very useful report.I am going to Be sure to be looking at through your weblog added. You designed an excellent stage but I can't aid but ponder, How about the opposite side? !!!!!!Thanksบาคาร่าวอเลท

    ReplyDelete