Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Is Work Enough?

I wrote this piece three years ago and never published it. But I returned to it recently and it still resonates with me (though a lot has changed since then), so I’m publishing it now. 

    Recently I wrote my first piece for the Atlantic, and on the day it came out I woke up early because I was so excited. But people quickly started writing mean things about the piece, and because my skin isn’t as thick as it should be I called my mom in the hope that she would make me feel better.

    “I’m a little stressed too, actually,” she said.

    “Why?” I asked.

    “Well, your grandfather just went to the hospital,” she said. “They think he might’ve had a stroke.”

    Which reminds you that there are worse things than nasty internet comments. There are also worse things than strokes. The next week was a surreal blend of professional successes and family tragedies. A literary agent emailed an offer to represent me. My mom emailed that the true problem was not a stroke but a brain tumor. A national radio station asked for an interview. My mom said that the tumor was probably not a lymphoma but a glioblastoma, which has a median survival of 3 - 6 months.

    My focus on my work has led a collaborator to label me a “serious workaholic”, and a friend to tell me that “you can choose to not care about people”. And yet. It has been made so devastatingly clear to me that my work is not enough.

    Here is what professional successes feel like when a close family member is dying. It’s as if you’re sitting at an elegant restaurant with a spear through your chest and waiters keep bringing you beautiful courses. One asks you how your food is.

    “It’s lovely,” you say, “but I’ve got this large hole in my ribcage…”

    Work is not enough, but nor is it nothing. A few months after my grandfather died, it became clear that my relationship of four years was coming to an end. (This has not been the greatest year.) I was at a conference in Dublin, and I was supposed to give a talk, and I was a mess; I was sneaking into the bathroom between poster sessions to cry. But the talk went well, and I ended up winning my first best talk award. I accepted the certificate from the organizer, smiled at all the clapping scientists, and went straight outside to do some more crying. I was crying because I still felt terrible, but I was also crying because even in the midst of all the terrible, winning still felt good. As broken as I felt, my head was working fine, and that incongruity was surprising and reassuring: a fierce, raw triumph, this sudden awareness that, unlike the Titanic, I was mostly safely compartmentalized.

    My life feels emptier of late. But I am happy alone in my head -- I am rarely lonely or bored -- because of my work. I do not think I would find my work comforting if I were pulling 90-hour weeks at Goldman Sachs, though. I am as addicted to pageviews and likes as anyone else, but I think I would find them less meaningful if they were for, say, a cigarette ad campaign I had designed. When I am at my computer, no matter what terrible things are happening, I can still put one word in front of another and think: the world may be bad, but maybe this will make it slightly better.

    Or maybe I just find my work comforting because it is safe: it’s a world as still and beautiful as a frozen wasteland, filled with abstractions I understand, problems that demand my full attention and leave no room for sadness. Science fiction writers seem to like this sort of psychotherapy. In Ender’s Game, a 6-year-old genius finds comfort far from home by computing powers of two. I used to try this, but I mostly got irritated because, unlike the 6-year-old, I can’t get up to 67 million in my head. In 2001: A Space Odyssey, after a rather serious mishap with a computer [1] leaves a character stranded alone, he finds comfort by listening to the “abstract architecture” of Bach. There is, if not deep satisfaction, at least distraction in abstraction.
[1] Probably programmed by a Cal student.


  1. Hi Emma. Longtime fan. Sorry to hear about your hard year.

    I don't find work, by itself, "enough." I appreciate your writing about it.

    That said, I work in public health - specifically the intersection of epidemiology / statistics and social justice. It's a fascinating shared space - as I'd guess you know a fair bit about, since you've written about some topics in that space too. I'm also lucky to often work with community groups, or local and state government - to lend some data support to community interests.

    Though I don't find work alone "enough," I am lucky to find meaning in my work in two ways I've come to really appreciate: (1) meaningful relationships, with fellow social-justice-aligned researchers and community leaders, and (2) contributing to meaningful change-making, by shortening the loop (sometimes, chasm) between statistics and practice, public health policies and community organizing I believe in.

    This, for me, was part of my realization leaving my purely engineering undergrad for a broader STEM + liberal arts education and then practice in the non-profit / government space - while I take meaning (and solace, like you talk about!) in the intellectual stimulation, often abstracted, of the work itself... the content, and the people, matter a ton for my mental health.

    No suggestion here, of course. I appreciate your writing what you did, and often appreciate your research interests and efforts. Thanks for doing what you do. Best wishes!

  2. Hi Emma,

    I am also a (very) long time reader and fan of your writing. I'm sorry to hear that you've had a particularly bad year personally, and I greatly appreciate you being open about it.

    As a (female) PhD student in STEM, reading your blog is a cathartic release for me - it's such a relief to read some of your opinions, some of your musings on being a woman in science, and see my own experiences being reflected in what you observe. Similarly, when reading this post I found myself nodding along - not to say that I understand how you feel, but just that there are elements of what you wrote that seem to reflect what I have been experiencing. Retreating to work in the middle of personal crises, and finding comfort in words.

    In the end what got me through trying times was not, surprisingly, being a workaholic, but the deep satisfaction and meaning I got from feeling like I was contributing to the community (a struggle when you are doing a PhD full time), and many meaningful discussions with close friends after I started speaking out about my struggles.

    I hope that you are in a better space since you wrote this. Regardless, I want you to know that I greatly appreciate all you are doing. Good luck, and best wishes!


    For getting the best essays written hire the Professional Essay Writers of all Assignment Help who have knowledge in every field to write the best essays for you.

  4. A superior All Assignment Help reviewoffered by this website with the advantage of online support with high proficiency level based on its latest research and information by professional reviews writers. Wide ranges of
    subjects are covered with separate writers for each subject.

  5. We Provide assignment help for students especially in usa getting brilliant quality reviews writing USA, essays and dissertations.We at Top Quality Assignment believe that there is no shortcut to success and to attain success, hard work, dedication, and commitment must be reviews 

  6. we always do not have enough time for us. so that you can have more time on yourself, you can get an oonline homework help, then our authors will write your task for you, and you can devote more time to yourself

  7. Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.
    Packers And Movers Bangalore

  8. In the end what got me through trying times was not, surprisingly, being a workaholic, but the deep satisfaction and meaning I got from feeling like I was contributing to the community (a struggle when you are doing a PhD full time), and many meaningful discussions with close friends after I started speaking out about my struggles.
    Mira Daihatsu Car Parts In Pakistan
    Daihatsu Move Car Parts In Pakistan
    X-Pv Car Parts In Pakistan
    Honda Civic Car Parts In Pakistan
    Honda City Car Parts In Pakistan
    Honda Fit Car Parts In Pakistan

  9. Regression therapy covers past lives, and furthermore current life memories some of which might be beneath the level of our cognizant mindfulness. It empowers the contentions from the past that have been misshaping our psychological, passionate and physical prosperity to be settled.
    Past Life Regression Training

  10. Packers and Movers Chennai Give Safe and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services in Chennai with Reasonable ###Packers and Movers Price Quotation. We Provide Household Shifting, Office Relocation, ✔✔✔Local and Domestic Transportation Services, Affordable and Reliable Shifting Service Charges @ Packers And Movers in Chennai

  11. I like that thing of being compartmentalized.

  12. provides online finance assignment help 24/7 throughout the year. Students can easily avail finance assignment help from team of experienced finance assignment writer.

  13. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post. Thanks for posting Really Such Things. I should recommend your site to my friends. It is of a great advantage to take custom essay writing service help. It eases the burden of students which they have to carry. Taking assignment help also gives a lot of benefits to the students. Our my essay writing service is highly committed to helping academic students to finish their essay.

  14. Thanks for sharing this blog post, such extraordinary data, Appreciate the positive input. I generally like these stuff. Similarly, we examined the substance on the pages of the site, including best Assignment Help writing service specific things, thanks and keep it up.

  15. Thank you so much for sharing this informative blog. Visit for
    Anonymous Hosting

  16. I am very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best posting. Assignment Help Australia

  17. Great site and a great topic as well I really get amazed to read this. It’s really good. I like viewing web sites which comprehend the price of delivering the excellent useful resource free of charge. brass bells

  18. Hi dear, your blog was really informative and valuable as I read before sometimes. Thank you so much for sharing this kind of informative post. Visit for
    Web Design Company in Delhi
    SEO Service in Delhi